Once an alcoholic always an alcoholic.In all fairness, oldr, as you know there's no such thing as a 'recovered' alcoholic/addict
However, as the Big Book states:
We do not have a drinking problem, we have a sobriety problem.This is the Foreword as it appeared in the first printing of the first edition in 1939.
We, of Alcoholics Anonymous, are more than one hundred men and women who have recovered from a seemingly hopeless state of mind and body. To show other alcoholics precisely how we have recovered is the main purpose of this book. For them, we hope these pages will prove so convincing that no further authentication will be necessary. We think this account of our experiences will help everyone to better understand the alcoholic. Many do not comprehend that the alcoholic is a very sick person. And besides, we are sure that our way of living has its advantages for all.
Our real malady is a "hopeless state of mind and body". When someone says they have "recovered" they do not mean they are cured of alcoholism. AFAIK no "Real" alcoholic has ever been cured of his/her "alcoholism". (for the definition of a "Real Alcoholic" read the first 46 pages of the BB. I think it's the first 46 pages, maybe more.)
I cannot safely drink alcohol ever again. I have the physical allergy that when I do drink, I am unable to stop. Then the mental obsession kicks in and tells me I can drink with no problems, that I can control it this time, that I can be like any other person and drink safely.
Just as a person who is allergic to poison ivy. They touched it and got the rash. Then they have recovered from that rash but cannot touch poison ivy again lest they get the rash again. They are still allergic to poison ivy just as I am still allergic tio alcohol.
But to me it's a matter of what someone wishes to call their own situation. Some like to say "Hi I'm X, recovered alcoholic" others say "recovering" and other like to use other forms of greetings. One guy in my group uses "Hi, I'm an alcoholic and my problem is John". John is not his real name, I am keeping that anon, I just say "Hi, I'm oldr, alcoholic". I should change my last name to "Alcoholic"

Alcohol was our medicine, our cure for our ills. Take that away and we are still left with our ills. I have heard many alcoholics who quit, were not recovered, being told by their family that they liked them better when they were drinking. The second part of the first step "-that our lives had become unmanageable" does not mean that alcohol had made our lives unmanageable (which it did). Our lives, or something in our lives was unmanageable and we drank to make that go away. Take away alcohol and the unmanageable part still remains.He completed none of the steps and was the most miserable abusive dry drunk bastard you can imagine
Yes I did, still do. The word "God" still conjures up the RC God who's representatives (aka nuns and brothers) punished little "oldr" in His name. I have moved on from that but stil have a hangup on the word "God" and still prefer "Higher Power". But the pragmatist in me tells me to economy of syllables and "God" is only one where as "Higher power" is four. that's the engineer in mebut rely on their own understanding of higher power to succeed in the program - if I recall correctly, didn't you also grapple with that issue early on?

But as my mentor (the words "sponser" and "sponsee" are never used in the Big Book) says, my concept of my Higher Power is not what it was a year ago, nor will it be the same a year from now.
Prayer alone will not heal us. Going through the Steps (sometimes multiple times) and changing the person that we once were, with the connection to a Higher Power as a foundation, is the miracle/cosmic coincidence/divine guidance/whatever that we get for our work.and truly dealing with the root issues that cause the behavior - the results can be miraculous in the lives of the alcoholic/addict and his/her loved ones, but it takes a whole lot more than prayer.
Sorry to break your post up into pieces and in no special order. Hope I made sense. Thanks for listening and understanding.