Plan B Forum

Quakes, injection disposal of fracking water linked

David R. Baker
Updated 5:46 am, Saturday, July 13, 2013

America's boom in oil and natural gas production may have triggered an unwelcome side effect - earthquakes.

A new study in the journal Science finds that the number of temblors shaking the central and eastern United States has soared in recent years, even as the controversial practice of hydraulic fracturing has opened up those regions to oil and gas drilling.

More than 300 earthquakes stronger than magnitude 3 struck in the last three years, according to the study. In the past, the central and eastern states experienced an average of 21 similarly sized quakes each year.

The problem does not appear to be hydraulic fracturing - or fracking - itself. Instead, many of the quakes erupt near wells where the dirty water left over from fracking, or other oil and gas operations, is injected deep underground for permanent disposal.

"The people in the industry I've talked to, they're very cognizant of this problem, and they're concerned about it," said study author William Ellsworth, a geophysicist with the U.S. Geological Survey.

The use of fracking is on the rise in seismically active California. If the practice takes off, it could lead to more deep injection wells. California regulations do not prevent companies from drilling injection wells near faults, although the rules do limit injection pressure.

The state already has about 2,300 injection wells, according to Ellsworth's study. But few of them are in areas with high seismicity. The potential link he sees between wells and quakes in states such as Arkansas and Oklahoma doesn't seem to be happening here.

"Rather than be worried, we should be informed," Ellsworth said. "We should ensure that better monitoring is done at injection sites. If we see changes in (seismic) behavior, they could be a warning that things are going to get worse."

California has been one of the nation's top oil-producing states for more than a century. But the increased use of fracking has touched off a bitter fight in Sacramento, with environmentalists and their political allies pushing to regulate the practice or stop it altogether. Oil companies have turned to fracking as a way to unlock the Monterey Shale, a vast geologic formation that could hold an estimated 15 billion barrels of oil.
Need for information

The possibility of triggering more earthquakes in a state that has, at times, been devastated by temblors has become part of the fracking debate. A bill from state Sen. Fran Pavley, D-Agoura Hills (Los Angeles County), would launch an extensive study of fracking's pros, cons and risks - including seismicity. The bill would halt all fracking in the state unless the study is completed by 2015.

"This underscores how little we know about the risks of fracking," Patrick Sullivan of the Center for Biological Diversity, an environmental group that wants a fracking ban, said of the new study. "The state needs to go back to the beginning and rethink the whole regulatory framework around fracking."

The oil and gas industry considers seismicity near injection wells a relatively minor problem, one that can be managed by siting the wells correctly and monitoring their pressure. Steve Everley, a spokesman for an industry-funded advocacy project called Energy in Depth, noted that the vast majority of the nation's deep injection wells have not been linked to earthquakes.

"It's a well-known thing," he said. "It's also an exceedingly rare thing. It's one of the risks that you try to manage."
Water, sand, chemicals

Hydraulic fracturing involves pumping a mix of water, sand and chemicals into wells at high pressure to crack subterranean rocks that contain oil or natural gas. The process itself can trigger quakes, but they tend to be too small for people to notice, Ellsworth said. The largest quake directly linked to fracking was a 3.6-magnitude temblor in British Columbia's Horn River Basin in 2009, he said.

Hydraulic fracturing involves pumping a mix of water, sand and chemicals into wells at high pressure to crack subterranean rocks that contain oil or natural gas. The process itself can trigger quakes, but they tend to be too small for people to notice, Ellsworth said. The largest quake directly linked to fracking was a 3.6-magnitude temblor in British Columbia's Horn River Basin in 2009, he said.