I'd like to also make clear what my personal position about this whole Obamacare deal is:
I was opposed to the legislation; and I would never have voted for it. Principally because I felt that the final bill was largely a giveaway to the insurance companies and also did nothing to address the primary underlying problem with the US healthcare system; the spiraling cost. I would actually have preferred that a public option be included, because it's my belief that a public option would have increased competition, which in turn would have created a downward pressure on insurance costs. I said so at the time.
I was not opposed to it because I am ideologically opposed to the concept of universal healthcare. I also have never been obsessed about Obamacare, and I was
adamant in my opposition to shutting down the government over it. Here's what I said in September:
I have no idea, (I don't believe anyone does) what the actual impacts and effects of Obamacare will be, (wildly divergent claims and predictions have been made on both sides) but at this point it seems to me we're now going to have a national laboratory (one of the nice things that our federal system provides) to test this, and find out who's claims are correct...
Let me also say that at this point, despite my initial opposition and skepticism about Obamacare, at this point I would prefer that it
not completely implode, and that the most dire predictions not turn out to be true. In addition to the severe economic pain this would cause the public, it could also re-invigorate the Tea Partiers, and I think I've made pretty clear what I think of them.
However, as the Santa Cruz Pseudo Scientist is so fond of saying "facts are facts" and all the initial facts as this is beginning to unfold all bode very ill...
The most important numbers in all of this are 7 million, and 2.7 million. These are the numbers, that by the Administration's own admission, (7 million total paid sign ups, of which 2.7 are young healthy people) which
must be met by the end of the open enrollment period (March 31st) in order to make the other two primary promises (in addition to the "if you like your plan you can keep your plan" pledge, which is now, to borrow a term from Ron Zeigler, "inoperative" ) this was sold on true. The promise that people would now have better coverage at the same or even lower rates, and that Obamacare would actually represent a
savings to the Federal government.
All the available evidence to date shows that hitting those essential numbers in the time available is going to be a monumental task, made all the more monumental by the website clusterfuck. And every day that goes by where the numbers aren't met needed to get to those totals is a day that makes achieving them that much tougher. (Whether you love Obamacare, hate Obamacare, or are indifferent to Obamacare, these are facts.)
And if this is not achieved, it will create a cascade effect sending premiums skyrocketing and blowing a huge whole in the budget effect projections. (And then of course we have the employer mandates kicking in, and who knows what nasty box of surprises await us then)
Another basic problem here is that in order for Obamacare to have
any chance of performing as advertised there has to be a basic public perception that it
will work, (particularly among younger people). And the rollout debacle, followed by millions of people being knocked off their health insurance plans despite the President's repeated promises to the contrary, and the ongoing sign up rates running far below what's needed, certainly aren't helping in this regard.
Anyone who is a strong supporter of Obamacare and really wants it to be a success ought to be worried as hell right now...
Not playing Little Susie Sunshine and whistling past the graveyard like our good buddy rube...(Rube's attitude reminds me of that scene near the end of
Animal House, where Kevin Bacon's character is standing in the middle of the side walk amidst complete pandemonium yelling "All is well!"...)
The bottom line is this:
If at the end of the day, if all that Obamacare achieves is getting a lot of folks signed up for expanded Medicaid who previously had no insurance (and let me stipulate, that taken in isolation, providing healthcare for those who cannot afford it, is a good thing) at the cost of screwing over just about everyone else and tanking the economy, there will be an
enormous political price to pay.
And while the bulk of that price will fall directly on the Democrats, it will also be borne by my party in the form of a re-vitalized Tea Party (at precisely the time when their influence finally seems threatened) which I believe would be disastrous both for the GOP and for the country for reasons that go far beyond Obamacare. (So I am actually a person who reluctantly hopes it
does not work out this way. I am not "rooting" for the failure of Obamacare.)
But if it does, instead of being his great signature achievement, The Affordable Healthcare Act will be Obama's Iraq War....