Crackpot wrote:The problem is we are applying time to a being that exists outside of time. It's like describing a 3rd dimension only using linear geometry it can't be done.
No, we are doing no such thing. You evidently would like us to be doing that, because you evidently believe that it provides some sort of solution to the problem. (Although how simply waving the slogan "outside of time" at what you admit to be a paradox resolves that paradox is anything but clear.)
Yet again: The issue here is the possibility of the existence of
human free will. Human beings exist and operate in a temporal universe, so if human free will exists at all, it exists and operates in a temporal universe. In the temporal universe in which we exist and operate, God knows what "choices" I will make before I make them. Therefore, the outcome of my supposed "choices" is determined before I make them. That negates the assertion that I have free will.
If you want to discuss issues related to whether God has free will -- as to which God's extratemporality or omnitemporality or both might well be relevant -- feel free to initiate such a conversation. At the moment, however, we are discussing human free will, and God's asserted timelessness (or however one wishes to describe it), being an attribute of God and not an attribute of human beings, tells us essentially nothing about the existence and operation of human free will in a temporal universe.
(By the way, the Bible shows no hesitation in describing God's knowledge as operating in the temporal universe, as in "Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee ...." (Jeremiah 1:5.))
Reason is valuable only when it performs against the wordless physical background of the universe.